Many women come to the doctor and say they want a "laser"
hysterectomy. What they usually mean is a laparoscopically
assisted vaginal hysterectomy or LAVH. The technique used to use
lasers but now lasers have been mostly replaced by surgical clips, cautery or suturing. It's really a
technique made to replace abdominal hysterectomy. If a vaginal
hysterectomy can be performed in the first place, there would be
no point in adding the costs and complications of laparoscopy.
I'm not sure what the impression is among women of why a LAVH is
desireable. I think many women believe it is safer than an
abdominal or even a plain vaginal hysterectomy. Most of the
medical literature supports that it has the same complications as
an abdominal or vaginal hysterectomy and IN ADDITION it has the
complications of laparoscopy. These include injury to major blood
vessels, the bowel or the urinary tract by the laparoscope
introducer (trocar) or the needle used to infuse carbon dioxide
into the abdominal cavity to facilitate visualization of the
pelvic structures. Another conception is that the LAVH is faster
to recover from. That part is actually true when it is compared
to an abdominal hysterectomy. Without a large abdominal incision,
there is less pain and recovery to normal activity is faster.
In a recent article, Kovac SR:Guidelines to determine the
role of laparoscopically assisted vaginal hysterectomy.Am J
Obstet Gynecol 1998;178:1257-63, the scientific data for the
various types of hysterectomy was analyzed and summarized.
Comparison of Hysterectomy Types
| Abdominal hysterectomy vs. LAVH | |
| Operating time | LAVH greater than abdominal hysterectomy
|
| Anesthesia time | LAVH greater than abdominal hysterectomy |
| Length of hospital stay | LAVH less than abdominal hysterectomy |
| Hospital charges | No difference |
| Vaginal vs. LAVH | |
| Operating time | LAVH greater than vaginal hysterectomy
|
| Anesthesia time | LAVH greater than vaginal hysterectomy |
| Length of hospital stay | No difference |
| Hospital Charges | LAVH greater than vaginal hysterectomy |
| |
Quality of life issues have also been studied and women
undergoing LAVH return to normal activity sooner, although at 4
weeks postoperative there is no difference. Right now about 2 out
of 3 hysterectomies are performed abdominally. Experts suggest
that up to 80% of hysterectomies could be done vaginally or LAVH.
|